Governance

Serious Case Review Quality Markers 

Quality statement

The Serious Case Review (SCR) achieves the requirement for independence and ownership of the findings by the Local Safeguarding Children Board (LSCB).

Rationale

Rigorous SCR analysis requires a significant degree of objectivity combined with sufficient understanding of context and organisational arrangements. Subsequently, changing practice is the responsibility of the LSCB and member agencies and they are more likely to be able to achieve this if fully engaged in and supportive of the findings of the SCR. Both these issues create a necessary tension between the independence of lead reviewer(s), on the one hand, and local involvement and ownership of the findings and/or recommendations by LSCB members on the other. Governance arrangements need to manage this tension to best effect.

How might you know if you are meeting this quality marker?

  1. At the start of the review, is there clarity about roles and responsibilities and are there explicitly stated governance arrangements (e.g. are the terms of reference/scoping document clear about who is responsible for what – who conducts the review, who provides quality assurance and challenge and who is ultimately accountable)?
  2. Is the system for quality assurance of the process and sign-off of the report set out clearly from the start?
  3. What are the mechanisms to allow challenge to the information and analysis of the review, so that the findings/recommendations have been thoroughly considered before the report is finalised and taken to the LSCB?
  4. Do the quality assurance mechanisms manage the tension between the independence of the lead reviewer(s) and the ownership of the final report by the LSCB in a fair and balanced fashion?
  5. Is there clarity about what happens when agreement cannot be reached about the analysis and findings/recommendations, and how impasses are handled?
     

Knowledge base

Link to statutory guidance & inspection criteria

Tackling some common obstacles

Downloads

All SCIE resources are free to download, however to access the following downloads you will need a free MySCIE account:

Available downloads:

  • Governance - Serious Case Review Quality Marker
  • Overview: Serious Case Review Quality Markers
  • Full report: Serious Case Review Quality Markers