Key statistics
- the study draws on 65 semi-structured interviews with policy stakeholders across the UK between 2019 and 2021, alongside analysis of 31 policy documents relating to social care reform
- interview participants included stakeholders across government, local authorities, care providers, NHS organisations and third sector groups in England (22), Wales (17), Scotland (13) and Northern Ireland (13)
- Scotland introduced free personal care for people aged 65 and over in 2002, later extending it to working-age disabled people in 2019
- England legislated for a cap on social care costs through the Care Act 2014, but implementation was repeatedly delayed due to financial and political pressures
Key messages
- social care reform in the UK has been slow and uneven despite widespread agreement that reform is necessary
- policy “drift” occurs when policies remain unchanged even as social needs increase or circumstances change
- Scotland has progressed further in social care funding reform than the other UK nations, particularly through free personal care
- England has experienced the greatest delays due to factors such as political disagreement, financial pressures and institutional complexity
- Wales and Northern Ireland have introduced some policy changes but have also faced barriers including institutional capacity and political instability
Policy implications
- social care reform requires long-term political commitment and cross-party agreement
- funding reforms should address the balance between public funding and individual contributions to care costs
- policymakers should consider how institutional structures and political systems affect the ability to implement reforms
- greater policy coordination across UK nations may help identify effective reform approaches
- sustained policy attention is needed to avoid continued delays in addressing long-term care funding challenges
Gaps
- the research focuses on national-level policymaking and does not examine how reforms are implemented locally
- the study relies on interviews with policy stakeholders and does not include direct perspectives from service users or carers
- the analysis primarily examines funding reform rather than broader aspects of social care quality or workforce issues
- further research is needed to understand how different funding models affect access to care and financial risk for individuals
Commentary
This study explores why social care reform has progressed unevenly across the four nations of the UK. Despite widespread recognition that the current system needs reform, many proposed changes have been delayed or only partially implemented.
The authors use the concept of policy drift to explain this pattern. Policy drift occurs when existing policies remain in place even though social needs and pressures have changed. In the context of social care, demographic ageing and rising care needs have increased pressure on systems that were not originally designed to cope with these demands.
The research compares England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, each of which has responsibility for its own social care system following devolution. Although these systems share common origins, they have developed in different ways over the past two decades.
Scotland has taken the most significant steps towards reform. In 2002 it introduced free personal care for older adults, a policy that later expanded to include working-age disabled people. This approach represents a form of “risk pooling”, where the costs of care are shared across society rather than falling mainly on individuals.
England has experienced greater delays in reform. Although legislation introduced in 2014 proposed a cap on the amount individuals would have to pay for care, the policy was repeatedly postponed due to financial and political concerns. Wales and Northern Ireland have made some changes to funding arrangements but have also faced institutional and political barriers.
The study identifies several factors that can lead to policy drift. These include the high cost of reform, political disagreements between parties, the complexity of the social care system and competing policy priorities. In England, these factors have combined to slow progress more than in the other UK nations.
From a health and social care equity perspective, the findings show how differences in political systems and policy decisions can lead to uneven social care arrangements across the UK. People living in different nations may face different rules around care funding and access to services.
Overall, the study highlights how institutional and political factors shape the pace of social care reform. Without sustained political commitment and agreement on funding solutions, policy drift may continue to delay reforms designed to protect people from the high costs of care.
Key statistics
- 19% of England’s population lives in rural areas, yet these areas cover around 85% of the country’s land area
- people living in rural areas generally have better overall health outcomes than those in urban areas, including longer life expectancy
- however, rural areas contain small pockets of significant deprivation and poor health outcomes that may be hidden within overall averages
- rural populations tend to be older on average, with higher proportions of residents aged 65 and over compared with urban areas
- the sparsity of rural populations and greater travel distances can affect access to services, employment and support networks
Key messages
- overall health indicators in rural England often appear favourable, but they can mask significant local variations in deprivation and health outcomes
- rural populations are typically older, increasing demand for health and social care services
- geographic sparsity and distance between communities can influence access to services and support
- local authorities need detailed knowledge of rural populations to identify hidden health challenges
- better local data and more granular statistics are needed to reveal health disparities within small rural communities
Policy implications
- improve local data collection to identify hidden deprivation and health needs in rural areas
- develop rural-specific public health strategies rather than relying on national averages
- strengthen collaboration between health services, social care providers and local authorities in rural communities
- consider transport, service accessibility and population ageing when planning rural services
- support community-based approaches that address local health needs in dispersed populations
Gaps
- national and regional statistics often mask variation within rural communities
- limited granular data exists on health outcomes in smaller rural settlements
- further research is needed to understand how service accessibility affects health outcomes in rural areas
- more evidence is needed on the effectiveness of rural-focused public health interventions
Commentary
This report examines the health and wellbeing of people living in rural England and highlights the complexity of rural health outcomes. Rural areas cover most of England’s land area but contain a relatively small proportion of the population. Despite this, rural communities play an important role in the national health and social care landscape.
On average, people living in rural areas experience better overall health outcomes than those living in urban areas. For example, life expectancy tends to be higher and some health indicators appear more favourable. However, these averages can hide important differences within rural communities.
The report emphasises the presence of “hidden deprivation” in rural areas. Small pockets of poverty and poor health may exist within otherwise affluent rural districts. Because rural populations are smaller and more dispersed, these issues may be less visible in national or regional statistics.
Rural populations also tend to be older than urban populations. Higher proportions of residents aged 65 and over increase demand for health and social care services, including community support and long-term care.
Geography plays an important role in shaping access to services. Rural communities often experience longer travel distances to healthcare facilities, fewer public transport options and limited availability of specialised services. These factors can make it more difficult for people to access timely support.
From a health and social care equity perspective, the report highlights the importance of recognising rural diversity. While some rural areas experience strong health outcomes, others face significant challenges linked to deprivation, ageing populations and limited service access.
The report argues that local authorities need detailed understanding of their rural populations in order to identify and address these challenges. More granular data and locally tailored policies may help ensure that rural communities receive appropriate support and that hidden inequities in health and wellbeing are addressed.
Key statistics
- adult social care in England is delivered by more than 14,000 provider organisations, creating a large and highly fragmented market
- around 840,000 people receive long-term social care support, many of whom rely on services delivered by independent sector providers
- approximately 84% of adult social care services are provided by the independent sector, including private and voluntary organisations
- local authorities purchase a large proportion of care services but do not directly control the structure of the provider market, which has developed through private and voluntary sector provision
- the Covid-19 pandemic placed significant financial and operational pressure on providers, highlighting existing vulnerabilities in the market
Key messages
- the adult social care provider market in England is highly fragmented, with thousands of organisations delivering services
- long-term structural pressures, including funding constraints and workforce shortages, affect provider sustainability
- the Covid-19 pandemic exposed existing weaknesses in the social care market
- local authorities play a key role in commissioning services but have limited influence over market structure
- reform efforts must address wider structural issues rather than focusing solely on funding increases
Policy implications
- strengthen oversight and support for the sustainability of social care providers
- review commissioning and contracting practices to promote stable service provision
- improve long-term funding arrangements for adult social care
- support local authorities in market shaping and service planning
- develop national strategies that consider the structure and resilience of the provider market
Gaps
- the report focuses on market structure rather than detailed analysis of service quality or care outcomes
- limited analysis is presented on how market fragmentation affects different regions or local populations
- further research is needed on the relationship between funding levels, provider sustainability and care quality
- additional evidence is required on how policy reforms may reshape the social care provider market over time
Commentary
This report examines how adult social care services are organised and delivered in England. Unlike the NHS, which is largely publicly funded and structured through national systems, adult social care is delivered through a complex market made up of thousands of independent organisations.
More than 14,000 providers deliver social care services across England. These organisations range from small local charities and family-run care homes to large national care companies. This diversity creates a highly fragmented system, where services vary widely in size, resources and organisational structure.
Local authorities play an important role in commissioning care services for people who are eligible for publicly funded support. However, most care is delivered by independent sector providers rather than directly by councils. This means that local authorities influence the market through commissioning and contracts but do not directly control how the market develops.
The report highlights long-standing financial pressures within the sector. Many providers operate on narrow financial margins, particularly when providing services funded by local authorities. These pressures can affect provider stability and the ability of organisations to invest in workforce development or service improvements.
The Covid-19 pandemic placed additional strain on providers. Increased costs, staff shortages and infection control requirements exposed existing weaknesses in the system and raised concerns about the resilience of the care provider market.
From a health and social care equity perspective, the structure of the provider market can influence access to services. Differences in local provider availability, financial stability and commissioning arrangements may affect the availability of care across regions. Some areas may have a wider range of providers and services, while others may face shortages or limited choice.
Overall, the report argues that reform of the adult social care system must address the underlying structure of the provider market. Sustainable funding, stronger market oversight and clearer national strategy may be needed to ensure stable and equitable access to social care services across England.
Key messages
- the cost of delivering social care services continues to increase, with notable regional and sectoral variation
- workforce costs represent a major proportion of overall social care expenditure
- low pay and challenging working conditions contribute to recruitment and retention difficulties across the sector
- public funding has not consistently kept pace with rising costs of care provision
- detailed cost data is essential for planning and allocating resources within health and social care systems.
Policy implications
- funding allocations should reflect the true cost of delivering social care services
- workforce pay and conditions need to be addressed to support recruitment and retention
- policymakers may need to consider regional variation when determining funding distribution
- robust cost data can support evidence-based planning of health and social care services.
Gaps
- the report focuses on cost estimates rather than service outcomes
- limited analysis of how cost pressures affect access to services or care quality
- further research is needed on how financial pressures influence different population groups.
Commentary
This report provides a detailed overview of the financial structure of health and social care services by analysing the unit costs associated with different types of provision. By examining workforce expenses, service delivery costs and regional variation, it highlights the financial pressures facing providers and local authorities.
Workforce costs emerge as a central driver of rising expenditure. Staffing accounts for a significant share of care costs, meaning that wage levels, recruitment difficulties and staff turnover directly influence the financial sustainability of services. These pressures are particularly visible in domiciliary care, where travel time, fragmented working hours and insecure contracts can make recruitment more difficult.
The report also draws attention to variation in costs and funding between regions. Differences in local authority budgets, labour markets and service demand contribute to uneven financial conditions for providers. These variations can affect how services are delivered and funded across different areas.
From a care inequities perspective, the findings highlight how financial pressures can translate into uneven access to services. Where funding does not reflect the real costs of providing care, providers may withdraw from local markets or increase fees for self-funding individuals. This can leave people in some areas facing reduced service availability or higher personal costs, reinforcing disparities in access to care based on geography and financial resources.
Overall, the report demonstrates the importance of accurate cost data in understanding the financial foundations of the care system. Aligning funding with the real costs of service delivery is an essential step toward reducing financial inequities and ensuring that care services remain sustainable and accessible.
Key messages
- austerity policies introduced after 2010 led to substantial reductions in local government spending across Britain
- cuts were unevenly distributed, with more deprived areas experiencing greater reductions in funding
- reductions in central government grants significantly constrained the financial capacity of local authorities
- austerity has reshaped the relationship between central and local government, reducing local authority autonomy
- areas with the greatest social and economic need experienced the largest funding reductions.
Policy implications
- funding allocation mechanisms may need revision to better reflect local levels of deprivation and service demand
- greater fiscal autonomy for local authorities could help address regional disparities in service provision
- national policy decisions on local government funding can have long-term consequences for social care provision
- monitoring regional impacts of fiscal policy is important to prevent widening geographical disparities.
Gaps
- the study focuses primarily on funding distribution and does not examine detailed impacts on specific services such as social care
- limited exploration of the long-term consequences for service quality and outcomes
- further research is needed to understand how funding disparities translate into differences in care provision and access.
Commentary
This study examines how austerity policies reshaped the financial landscape of local government across Britain. The analysis demonstrates that reductions in central government funding were not evenly distributed, resulting in significantly different financial pressures across local authorities.
The authors show that areas with higher levels of socioeconomic deprivation experienced larger reductions in government funding compared with more affluent areas. Because these same areas often have higher demand for public services, including social care, the effect of funding reductions can be particularly pronounced.
The research also highlights changes in the relationship between central and local government. Reduced grant funding has constrained the capacity of local authorities to plan and deliver services independently, increasing reliance on locally generated revenue and limiting the scope for addressing rising service demand.
From an inequities perspective, the findings show how funding mechanisms can reinforce regional disparities. When areas with the highest levels of deprivation experience the largest funding reductions, the capacity to deliver essential services such as adult social care may be weakened precisely where demand is greatest. This dynamic can widen gaps in access to support across different regions.
Overall, the study contributes to understanding how national fiscal policy decisions shape the distribution of public services at a local level. Addressing financial inequities in social care will likely require funding approaches that more closely reflect the differing needs and service demands of local communities.
Key messages
- quality of care in residential homes is closely linked to available resources
- workforce culture shapes daily routines and philosophies of care
- care workers play a central role in translating organisational priorities into practice
- time pressures influence how care is delivered to residents
- divisions of responsibility within care homes affect staff experience and care outcomes.
Policy implications
- resourcing levels directly affect the capacity to deliver high-quality care
- workforce culture should be considered alongside staffing numbers
- clearer allocation of responsibilities may support safer and more consistent care
- time allocation per resident is a critical factor in care quality.
Gaps
- limited exploration of how responsibilities are divided across staff roles
- need for further research on time pressures and their impact on care delivery
- findings are based on residential care settings only
- wider system-level influences on care home resourcing are not examined.
Commentary
This study provides a detailed account of how care work is organised and experienced within residential homes for older people. By focusing on everyday routines and interactions, it shows how care quality emerges from the interaction between resources, organisational culture and staff practice.
The findings emphasise that good care is not solely a function of individual commitment. Workforce culture and material conditions shape what care workers are able to do, how time is prioritised and how responsibilities are distributed across teams.
From a care equity perspective, the study highlights how under-resourcing and time constraints can create uneven care experiences for residents. When staff are required to ration time or negotiate unclear responsibilities, some residents may receive more attentive care than others. These dynamics reflect broader inequities in how care is funded and organised, rather than individual failings of workers.
Overall, the paper stresses the importance of viewing workforce conditions as central to equitable care. Ensuring fair allocation of time, clarity of roles and adequate resources is essential if residential care homes are to provide consistent and dignified care for all residents.
Key statistics
- residential care workers make up around 40% of the adult social care workforce
- residential care workers are twice as likely to experience poverty and food insecurity compared with health workers
- around 1 in 10 residential care workers experience food poverty
- the adult social care sector is projected to need approximately 600,000 additional workers by 2031.
Key messages
- low pay and insecure working conditions place many residential care workers at risk of poverty
- deprivation among care workers is significantly higher than among comparable health workers
- cost-of-living pressures exacerbate existing financial insecurity
- workforce shortages are expected to increase demand for residential care workers
- demographic factors shape exposure to poverty and deprivation within the workforce.
Policy implications
- improving pay and working conditions is central to workforce sustainability
- targeted financial and employment support is needed for residential care workers
- workforce planning must consider living standards as well as recruitment targets
- addressing poverty among care workers may support retention and quality of care.
Gaps
- the report focuses on residential care workers rather than the wider social care workforce
- limited exploration of regional variation
- longer-term impacts of cost-of-living changes require monitoring
- further research is needed on the effectiveness of targeted support measures.
Commentary
This report provides a stark account of the financial realities faced by residential care workers in the UK. By documenting high levels of poverty and food insecurity, it challenges assumptions that employment in care provides a stable route out of deprivation.
The findings highlight how poor pay and insecure conditions are embedded within the structure of residential care. As demand for care grows, these conditions risk undermining recruitment and retention, placing further strain on an already stretched workforce.
For care equity, the report exposes a contradiction at the heart of the care system. Workers who provide essential support to older and vulnerable people are themselves disproportionately affected by poverty and deprivation. These disparities are not incidental but reflect how care work is valued and funded, with implications for workforce wellbeing and continuity of care.
Overall, the report argues that improving outcomes for people who draw on residential care cannot be separated from improving the living and working conditions of the workforce. Addressing poverty among care workers is a prerequisite for building a fair, resilient and sustainable adult social care system.
Key messages
- means testing remains a central mechanism for determining eligibility for publicly funded social care in England
- the system can create financial barriers for individuals seeking care
- middle-income individuals may face the greatest financial pressure because they often do not qualify for support but cannot easily afford care privately
- regional variation in costs and service provision contributes to uneven financial outcomes
- alternative funding models, including insurance-based approaches or savings incentives, have been proposed as potential reforms.
Policy implications
- reform of the means-testing system may be needed to reduce financial barriers to care
- clearer eligibility rules and thresholds could improve transparency and understanding of the system
- policymakers may need to consider alternative funding approaches to improve long-term sustainability
- financial protection mechanisms could reduce the risk of high out-of-pocket care costs.
Gaps
- the analysis focuses largely on economic modelling and system design rather than lived experience of service users
- limited qualitative insight into how individuals and families navigate the means-testing system
- further research is needed on the real-world impacts of proposed funding alternatives.
Commentary
Mayhew’s work examines how the structure of means testing shapes access to adult social care in England. The analysis highlights how eligibility thresholds and financial assessments determine who receives publicly funded care and who must pay privately.
A central finding is that the current system can place particular pressure on individuals with moderate assets. Those with lower incomes may qualify for public support, while wealthier individuals may be able to self-fund care. People in between these groups may face substantial costs without assistance.
The research also points to variation in how financial thresholds interact with local service costs. Differences in care markets and local authority funding can lead to uneven financial experiences for individuals depending on where they live.
From a care inequities perspective, the study highlights how financial eligibility rules shape who is able to access care and under what conditions. Means testing can create uneven burdens across different income groups and regions, influencing both the affordability of care and the willingness of individuals to seek support. In some cases, uncertainty around costs may discourage people from accessing services, potentially leading to unmet needs and greater reliance on informal care.
Overall, the analysis contributes to debates on the sustainability and fairness of social care funding in England. It suggests that reforms to the financing system may be necessary to reduce financial inequities and improve access to care while maintaining long-term system sustainability.